Comet impact simulations cast doubt on origin of life theory AI illustrationhow this picture was madeCAMBRIDGE, United Kingdom, Oct. 28, 2026 - A University of Cambridge-led study[1] in Scientific Reports[2] finds comets were an unlikely route for delivering the chemistry of life to early Earth. Dr Richard Anslow was the lead author.[3]
Computer simulations suggest most comets hit Earth too fast and too steeply for life's molecules to survive.[4] In 54% of 100,000 simulated bombardment histories, no comet delivered enough hydrogen cyanide.[5]
The study does not completely rule comets out.[6] Asteroids, volcanoes and hydrothermal vents are suggested as alternative sources.[7] Comets may also have delivered carbon molecules to Mars more easily than to Earth.[8] César Menor Salván, commenting on the work, noted that it assesses only direct delivery of hydrogen cyanide.[9]
Earlier sample return work found amino acids and DNA and RNA building blocks on asteroid Bennu, which had supported the idea of seeding from space.[10]Impact Insight. Speed and angle decide what an impact does, and they are also the numbers planetary defense teams calculate first for any incoming object. An impact does more than deliver energy: it can destroy almost all the fragile material the object carries.CAMBRIDGE, Reino Unido, 28 de octubre de 2026, Un estudio dirigido por la Universidad de Cambridge[1] publicado en Scientific Reports[2] concluye que los cometas fueron una vía poco probable para transportar los compuestos químicos de la vida a la Tierra primitiva. El doctor Richard Anslow fue el autor principal.[3]
Las simulaciones informáticas indican que la mayoría de los cometas impactaron la Tierra a demasiada velocidad y con un ángulo demasiado pronunciado para que las moléculas relacionadas con la vida sobrevivieran.[4] En el 54 % de los 100 000 historiales de bombardeo simulados, ningún cometa entregó cantidades suficientes de cianuro de hidrógeno.[5]
El estudio no descarta completamente la participación de los cometas.[6] Se proponen asteroides, volcanes y fumarolas hidrotermales como fuentes alternativas.[7] Asimismo, los cometas pudieron haber transportado moléculas de carbono a Marte con mayor facilidad que a la Tierra.[8] César Menor Salván, al comentar el trabajo, señaló que este evalúa únicamente la entrega directa de cianuro de hidrógeno.[9]
Trabajos anteriores de retorno de muestras habían detectado aminoácidos y componentes básicos del ADN y ARN en el asteroide Bennu, hallazgos que apoyaban la hipótesis del aporte de material desde el espacio.[10]Perspectiva sobre los impactos. La velocidad y el ángulo definen el efecto de un impacto, y son además los primeros datos que calculan los equipos de defensa planetaria ante cualquier objeto en trayectoria de aproximación. Un impacto no solo libera energía: puede destruir casi todo el material frágil que transporta el objeto.
Proof10 sources · 4 publishers · signed
What this stands on
University of Cambridge led a study challenging that comets helped start life on Earth. · sci.news
The study was published in the journal Scientific Reports. · sci.news
Dr Richard Anslow was the lead author of this study. · sci.news
A 2026 study claims most comets hit Earth too fast and steep for life molecules to survive impact. · sciencenews.org
54% of 100000 simulated comet bombardment histories had no sufficient hydrogen cyanide delivery to early Earth. · sci.news
The study does not completely rule out comets delivering life building molecules to Earth. · sciencenews.org
Asteroids, volcanoes or hydrothermal vents are suggested alternative sources for Earth's life chemicals. · sciencenews.org
Comets may have delivered carbon molecules to Mars more easily than to Earth. · sciencenews.org
César Menor Salván stated the study only assesses direct hydrogen cyanide delivery. · sciencemediacentre.esSpain
Prior research had found organic molecules including amino acids and DNA/RNA building blocks on asteroid Bennu, which had supported the space seeding theory. · Futurism
The one we could place publishes from Spain. 3 could not be placed by their address. None is an official body: that part stands on reporting, not on the underlying document or transcript.